The world’s music 2.0: Smithsonian Folkways vs. National Geographic

I received a promotional package a month or so ago from my generous and much appreciated press contact at Smithsonian Folkways. He has long been undaunting in servicing my internet radio requests, never hesitating to gin up their dreamy proprietary CD-burning machine to churn out digital transfers of extremely deep catalog releases. Is there any deep catalog more exciting than the (for-all-intents-and-purposes) endless Folkways trough? It’s not too much to ask of one to shell out $20 for a burned disc in a smart cardboard sleeve, reprinted with the original Ronald Clyne cover art, or $9.99 for a digital album download – even though the digital masters are pulled from clean LPs and not from the original tapes (we can’t expect THAT much, can we?), we’re damn lucky the music is available to us at all. The Smithsonian Global Sound site offers a peerless exploratory experience, and with PDFs available of every album’s notes and cover, SFW’s leap into the digital age sets an example for every archival outlet looking to similarly adapt and disseminate. (That’s not including their downloadable teaching manuals and quixotic – though potentially brilliant – “Synchrotext” process. As a representative of another digitized archive pursuing on-line feasibility, yes, there is plenty jealousy of SFW’s creativity and adventurousness, not to mention funding. Ah… funding.)

I do digress. The package: in addition to the specific requests that it fulfilled, the package also delivered the two CDs that have earned SFW 2008 Grammy nominations – Michael Doucet’s “From Now On…“, in the Best Zydeco or Cajun category, and the Mariachi Los Camperos’ “Amor, Dolor, Y Lagrimas,” for the Best Regional Mexican album.

I listened to, and don’t like, either of these albums. Doucet as a fiddler is above censure – he’s brilliant, and the world requires my saying so not at all – but just as I’d rather have his old-time Cajun sessions with Canray Fontenot any day over Beausoleil, I can do without his interpretations of New Orleans R&B (the unspoken other half of the title is “…Everything I Do Gonna Be Funky,” after Allen Toussaint) and the occasional blues. The arrangements are tasteful – just fiddle, acoustic guitar, accordion, and vocal at most – but they’re harnessed to a less-than-inspired repertoire, just too spit-shined, too World Cafe for my taste.

Doucet is spit-shine; the Mariachi Los Camperos are a damn Zamboni. To these ears, their brand of Mexicano Country-politano música ranchera is the Latin equivalent of those (now utterly dated) collections of folk material sung by George Hamilton IV or Hank Snow, and gussied up by Chet Atkins and Bob Ferguson. It’s slick as can be, with a pro horn section and able harpist. If I were fluent in Spanish, I’d probably find the conceits in the Camperos’ hands nearly as unbelievable as I find those concerning little graves, roving gamblers, and prisoners’ dreams when interpreted by Snow or Hamilton’s.

My complaints with these records, however, are purely aesthetic. To ignore the popularity of slick country music – whether the Nashville Sound (then or now) or música ranchera – or to ask Smithsonian Folkways to do so, would be arrogant and patronizing. I might hate it, but what Los Camperos do is a representation of a thriving vernacular music as it’s enjoyed in Mexico. It’s not exactly “folk music,” but it certainly reflects real folkways, as they continue to be reinterpreted and adapted by their inheritors. I might be giving Grammy nominators too much, or maybe too little, credit, but I have a feeling that this the kind of thing they love nominating.

Maybe the Grammies are due less for the goodness of these records, and more to Folkways, the label, for continually resisting the inclination to become a genre ghetto. This is the label that first brought us Michael Hurley; that enthusiastically pressed up Henry Cowell LPs (and, later, CDs!); Sounds of Frogs and the Human Body; Tony Schwartz’s radio collages; and some of the most poorly recorded, obscurely annotated, and wonderfully interesting ethnographic music albums ever dreamt up. Moe Asch was not a record exec like, let’s say, Alan Lomax was a producer; Lomax who would often turn a tape machine or a video camera off if his informant started playing a pop tune, of any variety, learned off the radio or a record.* Folkways never explicitly dictated the breadth of its big tent. The “folkways” themselves were never explictly defined, and 45 years on, they’re still not.

Meanwhile, “Inefficient supply chains lose $40 billion annually.” That’s what the IBM banner ad chides on National Geographic’s new Nat Geo Music site. Perhaps that’s the problem of getting “world music” to the masses? Well then, perhaps NG can help, by providing an efficient clearing house for and adequate representation of all of those international artists that go criminally overlooked by the MSMM (mainstream music media, anyone?). You know, like Femi and Fela Kuti; Cesaria Evora; Damien Marley; and this scrappy bunch of fellows you’ve probably never heard of, Vampire Weekend! Seriously, though – poking around the site, looking at the genres on offer, I’m at an utter loss. Does National Geographic truly think they’re providing a unique service, or just hoping to cash in on a wholly underwhelming aggregation of economically fail-safe “world music” artists? According to Wired, it’s the former** – a marketing experiment focused on the potentially lucrative fantasy of an international indie youth culture, and not, ultimately, with much interest in fashioning the musicological equivalent of their photo-journalism.

The site’s few artist entries that hint at any greater inspiration than can be hoped for from a Putomayo A&R suit (or, for that matter, Mat Whittington, head of Nat Geo Music and former manager of the Thievery Corporation, an “electronic music duo with international flavor”), have been cut whole cloth from the (former?) Calabash Music site, which is itself a strange and often frustrating grab-bag of mostly contemporary ethno-pop musics. The one potentially exciting program on offer here – of the endangered music and dance traditions of Gabon – is not accessible through the website; no, you must be a subscriber to National Geographic Music Television, currently only available, well, nearly everywhere but North America. In case you were wondering, that station shows no signs of greater adventurousness than that of the website; that is if I understand their stated focus on “top artists” correctly.

Michael Doucet and the Mariachi Los Camperos are, in their own genre-ific ways, “top artists.” Plenty like them, buy their records, nominate them for Grammies. But those top artists, in the SFW firmament, sit alongside the whole wild ensemble that is the Folkways catalog – not only just the one-offs mentioned above, but also the noble and awe-inspiring Central Asia and Indonesia series, among so many others. Look at their website and the first thing you see is a rotating gallery of Folkways LP covers dug up from the vaults; records that aren’t lost, or dead, but only sleeping, and that can be yours on CD, as we’ve said, for less than $20. The Folkways folks seem – and I bet they are – just as proud of those riches as they are of their Grammy nominations.

But I’m still waiting for proof that the lowest-common-denominating (with its concomitant, hopeful insistence on what was once – is still? – called the “long tail”) that outlets like National Geographic’s music site do to the world’s vernacular music benefits the local musical communities that are obscured the most by the world-beat market’s monoculture. If it did have any benefit at all, it would be because it inspires in listeners more adventurousness than they seem to be comfortable exploiting in themselves; listeners who shouldn’t be so underestimated as to be assumed to appreciate only the most highly processed spoonfuls of that murky pot-au-feu that goes by the name of “world music.” No matter how “top” the artists might be.

*There are some very funny documented examples of Lomax waxing rhapsodic about how old or authentic a song he’s just recorded – with the player agreeing, or just keeping mum – when in fact it’s some cheesy pop-cowboy number of rather recent composition.

**Indeed, Wired says approvingly, National Geographic wants no truck with “the sound of the rain forest, indigenous tribes, or things of that nature. Rather, Nat Geo Music is looking for modern-sounding bands from various countries that have the potential to attract listeners from other regions.” Ouch.

On the Art of Field Recording, Vol. 2

Several months ago Lance Ledbetter of Dust-to-Digital invited me to write the preface to the second volume of their invaluable compilations of Art Rosenbaum’s many decades of field recordings. That volume is now available, and I’m posting its preface here. If you’re unfamiliar, or haven’t gotten around to spending time with the Art of Field Recording sets, I can say unblemished by the promise or hope of any personal gain that they are among the most wonderful and important traditional music collections to emerge in the digital age…!

(I plan on this piece of writing being the last reprise on my complaints with the legacy of Harry Smith’s Anthology for the foreseeable future.)

The release of the first volume of Dust-to-Digital’s Art of Field Recording set last year was a cause for celebration, rivaled only by the ecstatic reception it was given in the press. Don’t misunderstand—there are many (some might say too many) vernacular music reissue projects every year, and many of them are very good, and provide happy coverage of otherwise forgotten or overlooked performers, regions, eras, or genres of American music. And of course those that are very good are very good regardless of how forgotten or overlooked they are by the press. But to see so many outlets positively kvelling (to use a word Art Rosenbaum’s grandmother might have used back in Paterson, New Jersey) over a four-CD set of field recordings made across 50 years by an art professor cum amateur folklorist was remarkable.

Most of the reviews of volume one made nearly requisite mention of Harry Smith’s landmark Anthology of American Folk Music, which for many also elicited a mention of Greil Marcus’ now all-too-familiar chestnut of the “Old, Weird America” that Smith saw his set mystically invoking. Rosenbaum writes below that he is “pleased and honored” to have his set compared to the Anthology. But, for all of its brilliant inclusions, juxtapositions, and revelations, the Anthology is in many ways Smith’s tribute to the tenacity of the record collector and his obsession with obscurity, rarity, and preciousness. It celebrates the highly collectible pre-war 78 and in the process rarifies not only those objects themselves but also their performers, pushing the likes of Charley Patton, Dock Boggs, and Columbus Fruge into some imaginary past of musico-mythological dimensions; a bestial, primitive, inscrutable place, filled with moans, howls, speech-in-tongues, and tribal utterances. We hear them, shiver, laugh, gape, and fall in love, but the Anthology keeps them distant and foggy, behind the cover’s presentation of the hand of God tuning a monochord.

The Art of Field Recording volumes take a different tack. They reveal, not obscure. While the music of both sets speak entirely and effectively for themselves, Art Rosenbaum makes clear his dedication to the undeniable living-ness of the songs, the essential, fundamental quality with which track after track is imbued. It takes fingers and toes to count how many songs end in laughter, a joke, or other gleeful outburst you can’t help but feel lucky to be let in on. And those of the sacred and the melancholy varieties sound so forcefully, throbbingly intimate that to listen can feel almost invasive, requiring the utmost gingerness and respect. These are performances which palpitate with organic presence, enduring with each listen as, in Rosenbaum’s words, “ever-renewing contexts, embodying time past in time present.” Listening to these volumes, it occurs to me how incomplete a portrait the commercial recording of rural American music painted in its pre-war heyday, and that, despite the years since of revivals, re-revivals, and “rediscoveries,” what Alan Lomax called the “deep river of song”—the living stream of musical inheritance, reinterpretation, and reinvigoration—can never be fully sounded. The best known performers included here—Scrapper Blackwell, Buell Kazee, Ola Belle Reed, Dewey Balfa; talents who have been if not exhaustively, at least thoroughly represented on prior releases—flow naturally and happily into voices who have been under-represented, under-appreciated, or often all but unknown. Why weren’t Doodle Thrower and his Golden River Grass regarded as one of America’s most original and thrilling bluegrass bands? Why haven’t there been albums devoted to Laurence Eller, whose voice is as singular and haunting as Roscoe Holcomb’s? Had Cecil Barfield run a juke joint, or perhaps lived in Mississippi instead of his native South Georgia, it’s easy to imagine him being as beloved and as sought after a subject for films and records as was Junior Kimbrough.

It’s Barfield that tells Rosenbaum, as you’ll read and hear, that in writing a blues, “What your heart do, your mind be right along with it.” Art reads this as an insistence on emotional primacy in creative expression. That’s a welcome approach to traditional music. It sees a partnership between the collective tradition and the individual artist, and Rosenbaum, an artist himself, explicitly understands his connections with the players of his field recordings as artistic connections. As he writes, these recordings speak, not “as quaint artifacts of the past, but as living art, renewed in performance, continuing to speak to the human spirit and condition.” If that’s not a definition of folk music, it’s indefinable.

Briefly off-message: from Leonard Cohen’s Book of Mercy.

As an American Jew watching with horror what is being done in Gaza in the name of “defending Western values” and the “war on terror,” not to mention the “defense” of the Jewish people, I feel compelled to share this piece of Leonard Cohen’s, from his 1984 “Book of Mercy.” It should be nailed on every telephone pole between here and Ashdod – and Khan Yunis and Gaza City, too – a la Martin Luther.

Shalom rav, al adamah am’cha. (Adonai,) grant peace to all mankind, your people.

*   *   *

Israel, and you who call yourself Israel, the Church that calls itself
Israel, and the revolt that calls itself Israel, and every nation chosen to
be a nation – none of these lands is yours, all of you are thieves of
holiness, all of you are at war with Mercy. Who will say it? Will America
say, We have stolen it, or France step down? Will Russia confess, or Poland
say; we have sinned? All bloated on their scraps of destiny, all swaggering
in the immunity of superstition. Ishmael, who was saved in the wilderness,
and given shade in the desert, and a deadly treasure under you: has Mercy
made you wise? Therefore the lands belong to none of you, the borders do not
hold, the Law will never serve the lawless. To every people the land is given
on condition, Perceived or not, there is a Covenant, beyond the
constitution, beyond sovereign guarantee, beyond the nation’s sweetest
dreams of itself. The Covenant is broken, the condition is dishonoured,
have you not noticed that the world has been taken away? You have no place,
you will wander through yourselves from generation to generation without a
thread. Therefore you rule over chaos, you hoist your flags with no
authority, and the heart that is still alive hates you, and the remnant of
Mercy is ashamed to look at you. You decompose behind your flimsy armour,
your stench alarms you, your panic strikes at love. The land is not yours,
the land has been taken back, your shrines fall through empty air, your
tablets are quickly revised, and you bow down in hell beside your hired
torturers, and still you count your battalions and crank out your marching
songs. Your righteous enemy is listening. He hears your anthems full of
blood and vanity, and your children singing to themselves. He has
overturned the vehicle of nationhood, he has spilled the precious cargo, and
every nation he has taken back. Because you are swollen with your little
time. Because you do not wrestle with your angel. Because you dare to live
without God. Because your cowardice has led you to believe that the victor
does not limp.